Here's my solution:
Anyway, I copied every song I play on a regular basis during the holidays and placed them (double sided) into the binder. I made sure I put them in an order that I could play from start to finish.
So, all my slow songs don't get played at the same time and all my upbeat songs don't get played together. This is helpful so that my arms don't want to fall off from exhaustion halfway through the book. I also have a few by the same artists and I tried to make sure they were evenly dispersed too. This way I have a nice mix of holiday music to play.